How to select the right candidate for your organization?

One of the challenges for most of the small, emerging organization is selecting the right candidate for the job and retaining in the organization. There could be many factors contributing to retaining the people, and we discuss in another forum. However, one of the typical scenario we are witnessing in most of the organization is that within a short time, say 1-3 months time, the business head and the incumbent conclude either person is not fit for the job, or the organization is not fit for the new incumbent. This scenario is more common in senior level recruitment.

A strange fact is that the business head had personally involved in shortlisting, interviewed the candidate and inducted for employment. If either one of them concludes " this is not fit for me," we can arrive a logical conclusion that " selection process needs to be improved".

Typical mistakes the business head do during the selection process?

1. On an ad-hoc basis, decide the requirement for manpower 
2. No job description or role clarity/ responsibility/accountability defined before shortlisting the candidate even though there is macro level articulation on the need.
3. Conducting the interview process  with the intent of understanding more about the  candidate's previous experience and not on verifying or calibrating his caliber is matching with the organization's prevailing business practices or the culture
4. No structured questioning to check the attitude/perspective of the candidate to solve the existing organizational challenges or issues
5. Sometimes, selecting the candidate based on the reference from a known circle or filling the position with " somewhat" fit candidates.

Impact of the poor selection process:

1. Attrition rate becomes high, and it affects the stability of the organization.

2. Business head spends his time in routine work which affects his productivity and other aspects of profitability and growth
3. Cost of recruitment keeps increasing with no return benefits.

4. The organization which has grown with old, loyal employees, the high attrition rate signals different communication among employee. Eventually lead to complacent mentality, arrogance, know it all attitude which affects speed and flexibility towards change 

5. Sustaining organization development and gearing up for next level growth with a professional mix of people will become a major challenge for the organization.

Solutions approach to improving the selection process:

As a business head, before filling and selecting the candidate, you need to be clear on the job description as follows

• Position description
• Age, Experience, and qualification
• what level of competency(Job Knowledge and Skills) you are looking for 
• what is your organizational culture and how would you like to check during the interview
• your affordable pay and structure
• Likely growth path to the incumbent and likely changes in the existing organization structure

Once you are clear on your expectation, circulate the job description to professional recruiters and get the potential candidates.

Scan through the potential people and shortlist a  few who fit into the above requirements.

During Interviewing the candidate:

Look for the attitude which is required for the position or title. Attitude can be tested by asking the following question and look at the response from the candidate.

1. Experience in handling people dynamics and his style of managing the challenges 

2. State some of your organizational scenario or challenges and ask how he would respond in those scenarios.

The quick or momentary response, to some extent, will reflect the person's natural attitude towards work and people as this help you to gauge the suitability of the person to your organization.

Also, You need to note that you are recruiting senior level people to bring a change and sustain the business growth. Hence be balance in your approach to select the person with a track record of change management and fit into your culture.

Since we are dealing with human dynamics, it is challenging to gauge people's capability and attitude in the interview time. However, having a systematic process and improving your interviewing skill will improve the probability of choosing a right people for the organization as it helps both you and the others!